BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Damage restoration

Estimating and insurance claims

Estimating and claims is the work of measuring the damage, pricing the repair line by line and agreeing with the insurer, or with a referee, what the policy pays.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1943 to 2026.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1943

    Disputes go to appraisal

    Massachusetts adopted the first standard fire insurance policy in 1873 and New York its first in 1886; New York's 1943 version, or statutory copies differing only slightly from it, is in use in nearly all US states, by the account of FC&S, an insurance reference service. It sets out appraisal: if insurer and policyholder cannot agree on the amount of a loss, each picks an appraiser, the two pick an umpire, and a written award signed by any two of the three fixes the actual cash value (the value of the damaged property at the time of loss) and the loss. Courts have set aside awards in which the appraisers or the umpire went past the amount and interpreted the policy, as a Nevada court did in St. Paul v. Wright (1981).

    LessonAppraisal settles how much, not whether the loss is covered.

    propertycasualty360.com

    Credit

    New York Legislature

  2. 2011

    Whole blocks settled from photos

    After the earthquake and tsunami of 11 March 2011, the General Insurance Association of Japan (GIAJ) marked "total loss areas" from aerial and satellite photographs, and its members paid homes there as total losses without sending loss adjusters. By late April 2011 insurers had paid about $2.27 billion on about 125,000 home claims, by GIAJ's figures as reported by Business Insurance. GIAJ used the same joint survey after the 2024 Noto Peninsula earthquake, where a total loss area is a city block in which every building was washed out or burned down.

    LessonA photograph can settle a claim where nothing is left standing; the method does not reach a partly damaged house.

    businessinsurance.comdkgubs12tyvz9.cloudfront.net

    Credit

    General Insurance Association of Japan

  3. 2019

    Florida limits water-claim assignments

    An assignment of benefits (AOB) lets a homeowner sign the insurance claim over to the contractor doing the work, often a water-drying firm called in an emergency, which then bills and, if need be, sues the insurer. Florida's insurance regulator reported that AOB use rose from 5.7% to 15.9% between 2010 and 2016. Citizens Property Insurance, the state-backed insurer, reported that the share of its litigated water claims carrying an assignment rose from 9.7% in 2012 to 55% in 2015, when a litigated water claim cost it $33,918 on average against $5,857 for one that was not litigated. A law signed on 23 May 2019 (HB 7065, Chapter 2019-57) let owners cancel an assignment within 14 days, capped an assignment signed in an emergency at the greater of $3,000 or 1% of the dwelling limit, and set a formula for who pays attorney fees. For policies issued from 1 January 2023, Florida law makes such assignments void.

    LessonFlorida changed the rule twice in four years, first limiting assignments and then voiding them in new policies.

    flsenate.govleg.state.fl.us

    Credit

    Florida Legislature; Florida Office of Insurance Regulation; Citizens Property Insurance Corporation

  4. 2019

    Labor depreciation ruled out

    Actual cash value is usually figured as the replacement cost minus depreciation, an allowance for age and wear. Whether depreciation may be taken from the labor in a repair estimate as well as from the materials has split courts. On 15 April 2019 the Tennessee Supreme Court, in a class action brought by homeowners against Auto-Owners, found policy wording that did not mention labor ambiguous and ruled that the insurer could not depreciate it, reasoning that labor does not age, wear or become obsolete. In December 2018 the Eighth Circuit had let an Arkansas class action over withheld labor depreciation go forward.

    LessonA single deduction in an estimate, applied the same way on thousands of claims, can become a class action.

    stblaw.comcontent.naic.org

    Credit

    Tennessee Supreme Court (Lammert v. Auto-Owners)

  5. 2022

    Photos, then a visit anyway

    J.D. Power's 2022 US Property Claims Satisfaction Study, of 5,724 homeowners who had filed claims, found that more customers were sending photos to help with the estimate, but only 11% used digital channels for all the main steps: reporting the loss, the estimate and status updates. Satisfaction was 47 points lower on its 1,000-point scale when customers sent photos and still had to arrange an in-person inspection. Customers who stayed digital throughout had repairs start nine days sooner.

    LessonPhoto estimating helped only when it replaced the visit, not when it added a step before it.

    insurancejournal.com

    Credit

    J.D. Power

  6. 2024

    Fee caps for public adjusters

    A public adjuster is a licensed adjuster whom the policyholder hires, for a fee, to prepare and negotiate a claim; 46 US states license them. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the body of US state insurance regulators, adopted a model licensing act for public adjusters on 22 May 2005. A revision adopted by its market regulation committee on 19 November 2024 caps fees at 10% of a catastrophe claim settlement and 15% of any other, bars assigning policy benefits to a repair contractor, and bars a public adjuster from holding any financial interest in a claim or referring the owner to a repairer in which the adjuster has one. Each state decides whether to adopt it.

    LessonThe rewrite answered four problems regulators named: unlicensed adjusting, contractors acting as adjusters on their own jobs, assignments of benefits and excessive fees.

    content.naic.org

    Credit

    NAIC Public Adjuster Licensing (D) Working Group

  7. 2026

    Rebuild estimates run low

    When a home policy is sold, the insurer sets the dwelling limit from a reconstruction cost estimate, usually made with tools from a few vendors such as Verisk and CoreLogic. Kenneth Klein of California Western School of Law analyzed California Department of Insurance data covering at least 98% of fire claims on owner-occupied homes from 2018 to 2023, 74,070 claims in all. Slightly more than seven in ten destroyed homes had dwelling cover below the insurer's own reported cost of the loss, by roughly 20% on average: about eight in ten by 25% in wildfires, and 68% by 17% in single house fires. The estimate made at the point of sale came in low 75% to 95% of the time, by more than 30% on average.

    LessonKlein traces most underinsurance to the insurer's own estimate, not to owners choosing low limits.

    lawcommons.lclark.eduinsurancebusinessmag.com

    Credit

    Kenneth S. Klein (Lewis & Clark Law Review, 2026)

Watch for

  1. Water claims settled from photos

    Verisk, which makes the Xactimate estimating program, says its XactGen Capture turns room photos and scans that policyholders take on their own phones, usually in under two minutes a room, into measurements, sketches and Xactimate estimates for qualifying interior water claims, so that no adjuster needs to visit. An experienced estimator reviews every result before it reaches the adjuster, and Verisk says the tool is "not unattended estimating".

    Achieved whenan insurer or an outside reviewer publishes, for claims handled this way, how often the photo estimate later needed a revision or a field visit, set beside claims inspected in person.

    verisk.com

    Claimed by

    Verisk, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Same loss, many estimates

    A blind test of how far estimators disagree on the same damage. Closed water-damage job files (room photos, a floor sketch, moisture readings and drying logs), shared with the owners' permission and with names removed, go to at least 20 estimators: insurers' desk adjusters, restoration contractors and independent estimators. Each prices them with the same price list. Publish the spread of totals for each job and the line items that cause most of the disagreement, and run AI estimating tools on the same files as a second comparison.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Settlement rules as code

    An open software library that works out what a home claim pays under each state's rules: actual cash value, the replacement-cost amount held back until the repair is done, deductibles, law-and-ordinance limits and limits on assignments. Each rule is tied to the statute, regulation or court ruling it comes from, and a public test suite of worked examples checks every one.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Same loss, many estimates

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A blind test of how far estimators disagree on the same damage. Closed water-damage job files (room photos, a floor sketch, moisture readings and drying logs), shared with the owners' permission and with names removed, go to at least 20 estimators: insurers' desk adjusters, restoration contractors and independent estimators. Each prices them with the same price list. Publish the spread of totals for each job and the line items that cause most of the disagreement, and run AI estimating tools on the same files as a second comparison.

Why it is still open

United Policyholders, a consumer group, says that an Xactimate estimate made by someone not properly trained in the program "will probably be wrong", usually on the low side, but gives no measured figures. A March 2026 guide from Loti on comparing two Xactimate estimates lists where they differ (sketches, scope by room, materials, price-list dates) without measuring how often. Two studies come close. In a 2020 workshop for the California Earthquake Authority, the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER) gave 11 claims adjusters prepared Xactimate files for earthquake-damaged houses, three to five adjusters per scenario and 74 estimates in all, and found that clearer instructions changed the results. Finch Claims, which sells software to public adjusters, found on 46 disputed claims that lower prices for the same repairs made up 85% of the gap between insurer and public adjuster ($7.2 million of $8.5 million), from its customers' files. Neither tested water losses blind with many estimators. AI tools that write or audit estimates now exist, from Verisk's XactGen to small GitHub projects such as claimscope, which sends photos to GPT-4o and exports to Xactimate, but none is scored against a shared set of files.

uphelp.orgrallybacks.loti.comapps.peer.berkeley.educlaimsjournal.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

Closed job files exported from a restoration firm's job software, with consent; one Xactimate price list fixed to a single month and region, so that only scope varies; a form that collects every estimate as rows of line items; a low-cost extraction model such as Muse Ember to read PDF estimates into rows (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python to align line items across estimates; current AI models given the same files.

  1. First step

    Ask one restoration firm for five closed water jobs with full photo sets and drying logs, remove personal details, and send them to five estimators with the same price list.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 jobs, each priced by at least 20 people, with the median total and the range between the 10th and 90th percentile for each job, agreement on the 20 most common line items, and AI tools' totals placed within the human spread. Files, estimates and code released under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Settlement rules as code

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open software library that works out what a home claim pays under each state's rules: actual cash value, the replacement-cost amount held back until the repair is done, deductibles, law-and-ordinance limits and limits on assignments. Each rule is tied to the statute, regulation or court ruling it comes from, and a public test suite of worked examples checks every one.

Why it is still open

The rules differ by state and change often. Courts disagree on whether labor may be depreciated, and Tennessee's Supreme Court ruled against it in 2019; Florida caps an emergency assignment at the greater of $3,000 or 1% of the dwelling limit and since 2023 voids assignments in new policies. The nearest work writes policies, not settlement law, as code: Stanford's CodeX center encodes health insurance terms as logic programs for students, and AXA uses a logic language for its policy wording and claims coverage checks, by their December 2024 white paper. A search of GitHub in November 2026 found no repository that writes home claim settlement rules by state.

stblaw.comflsenate.govlaw.stanford.edu

Built with what exists

Catala, a programming language designed for writing laws as code, or OpenFisca, an open engine for tax and benefit rules; Python and pytest for the tests; an AI model to draft rules from statute text, with a person checking each against the source.

  1. First step

    Write the Tennessee and Florida rules for one water claim as code, with ten worked test cases for each.

  2. Done looks like

    Rules for 10 states covering actual cash value, holdback, labor depreciation, matching and law-and-ordinance cover; at least 200 worked test cases, each traced to a source document, all passing; a second person checks a random 10% of the rules against their sources.