Industries / Consumer goods / Cosmetics and personal care
Packaging
Packaging is the container and the part that dispenses the product, from lipstick cases and pump bottles to spray cans and refills, and what becomes of it once it is empty.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1923 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1923
A lipstick that swivels up
James Bruce Mason Jr. of Nashville, Tennessee, was granted a US patent in October 1923 for a "toilet article", one of the "devices for holding articles such as lip sticks which are worn away during the use thereof". As the stick wore down, the user turned a screw at the base of the case to push it up. Mental Floss calls it the first swivel lipstick.
Credit
James Bruce Mason Jr
1978
Ozone-harming propellants banned
In 1974 the chemists Mario Molina and F. Sherwood Rowland reported in Nature that chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), gases then used to propel spray cans, break down high in the atmosphere and release chlorine that destroys ozone. The FDA, the EPA and the Consumer Product Safety Commission then phased CFCs out of "non-essential" sprays such as deodorants and hair sprays: making CFCs for most aerosols stopped on 15 October 1978, making the sprays on 15 December 1978, and shipping existing stock between states on 15 April 1979. By the EPA's count, fluorocarbons released from aerosols fell from 511 million pounds in 1973 to about 300 million pounds in 1977.
LessonA propellant can do harm far from where it is sprayed, so the gas in the can is part of a product's safety.
Credit
Mario Molina and F. Sherwood Rowland; FDA, EPA and CPSC
1990s
Refills dropped, then revived
The Body Shop, founded in 1976 with a first shop in Brighton, England, that sold 25 products, once ran a refill station for shower gels. It dropped the station in the 1990s "after customers failed to understand how it worked", The Week reported in 2019, when the chain put refills back into a new London store. In April 2021 the company said it would put refill stations for up to 12 products, including shower gels, shampoos and soaps sold in 250 ml aluminum bottles, into 400 stores by the end of that year.
LessonA refill scheme fails if shoppers do not understand how to use it.
Credit
The Body Shop
2022
Pumps without a metal spring
Conventional pumps on skin care bottles have a metal spring inside, which, PlasticsToday reported, makes them nonrecyclable. Aptar made a pump for Dermalogica with a plastic spring, so the pump can go through recycling with the bottle, and the Association of Plastic Recyclers (APR), a US industry group, recognized it under its Design Meets Preferred Guidance program. Dermalogica planned to start using it on three cleansers in 2022.
Credit
Aptar; Dermalogica; APR
2025
Leftover product measured
Researchers at FH Campus Wien, a university of applied sciences in Vienna, developed tests for how much product stays in a pack once it has been used up, and ran them on shampoo, hair gel, hand cream, body lotion, face cream, eye cream and serum. Jars and airless pump dispensers, which do not let air back into the pack, held back less than 1% of hand cream, while ordinary pump dispensers held back up to 26% of product.
LessonHow much product is thrown away depends on the pack as much as on the product.
Credit
Michelle Klein and Silvia Apprich, FH Campus Wien; Manfred Tacker, Circular Analytics
2025
A packaging pledge missed
L'Oréal set itself two packaging goals for 2025: all of its plastic packaging refillable, reusable, recyclable or compostable, and half of its plastic packaging made from recycled or biobased (plant-derived) material. Its 2024 annual filing put the figures at 49% and 37%, Packaging Europe reported in April 2025. Its new goals include all plastic in its packaging from recycled or biobased sources by 2030 and a 20% cut in packaging intensity, the amount of packaging per unit of product, from 2019.
LessonA company's own yearly filings are where a packaging pledge can be checked, and here they showed it about half met.
Credit
L'Oréal's own figures; Packaging Europe
Watch for
Refills that save plastic
L'Oréal says its refillable options grew 3.7-fold from 2019 to 2025 and that its 2026 refill campaign covers 28 products from 18 brands. It says a 100 ml refill of Lancôme La Vie Est Belle Elixir saves 66% of the plastic used by two 50 ml bottles, and that a refill for Lancôme Absolue Longevity Soft Cream is expected to cut plastic by 42% against the standard jar. Packaging Europe's report names no outside check of these figures.
Achieved whenan outside party weighs the packs and confirms the savings, and L'Oréal publishes what share of its sales are refills.
Claimed by
L'Oréal, June 2026
Open
01
Refill packs on the scale
A public table of how much packaging refill systems really use. Buy the original pack and its refill for 30 or more skin care, hair care, soap and perfume products, empty, rinse and dry every part, and weigh each on a lab balance. Report grams of packaging per 100 ml of product for the first purchase and for each refill, beside the maker's stated saving.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Tear down the pumps
A public teardown table of the pumps and sprayers on skin care, hair care and liquid soap bottles on sale today. For each: a photo of the parts, the weight and plastic of each part, whether the spring is metal (a magnet test), and a recyclability grade under the APR Design Guide's rules for closures and dispensers.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Refill packs on the scale
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of how much packaging refill systems really use. Buy the original pack and its refill for 30 or more skin care, hair care, soap and perfume products, empty, rinse and dry every part, and weigh each on a lab balance. Report grams of packaging per 100 ml of product for the first purchase and for each refill, beside the maker's stated saving.
Why it is still open
The savings quoted for beauty refills come from the brands. L'Oréal's June 2026 figures for two Lancôme refills, 66% and 42% less plastic, carry no outside check in Packaging Europe's report. A web search for an independent weighing of beauty refill packs found brand figures and articles repeating them, but no published test. The 2025 FH Campus Wien study measured product left in packs, not the weight of the packs.
Built with what exists
A lab balance that reads to 0.01 g; calipers; photographs of each part; a spreadsheet or Python with pandas; Zenodo, a free research repository, to publish the data with a permanent identifier (DOI).
First step
Buy five original packs and their refills, including the two Lancôme products, and weigh every part.
Done looks like
At least 30 refill systems from at least 10 brands, each weighed by two people whose results agree within 1%; for each, the measured plastic saving next to the claimed one; and a count of how many claims fall within 5 percentage points of the measurement.
Open 02 · the brief
Tear down the pumps
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public teardown table of the pumps and sprayers on skin care, hair care and liquid soap bottles on sale today. For each: a photo of the parts, the weight and plastic of each part, whether the spring is metal (a magnet test), and a recyclability grade under the APR Design Guide's rules for closures and dispensers.
Why it is still open
Pumps without metal springs exist, such as the Aptar pump for Dermalogica that APR recognized in 2022, and PlasticsToday describes conventional skin care pumps as having a metal spring. The APR Design Guide grades closures and dispensers as design features, but it grades a design, not what is on shelves. A web search for a count of how many pumps on sale still carry metal springs or mixed plastics found patents and supplier news only.
Built with what exists
Pliers and a small screwdriver; a magnet; a lab balance that reads to 0.01 g; the resin codes molded into parts, checked where unclear with an infrared (FTIR) spectrometer in a university lab; the free APR Design Guide; a spreadsheet and Zenodo.
First step
Buy 20 pump bottles at a drugstore, empty and rinse them, take the pumps apart and settle the table's columns.
Done looks like
At least 100 pumps from at least 40 brands, bought in at least two countries, each with photos and part data; a second person repeats 20 teardowns and agrees on spring material and main plastic for all 20; the share of pumps with metal springs published with its margin of error.