BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Childcare

Staffing and ratios

Staffing is finding, training, paying and keeping enough carers, under rules that set how many children each adult may look after (the ratio), how big a group may be and what qualifications staff need.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1989 to 2024.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1989

    The military fixes its centers

    In 1982 the US General Accounting Office found that many Department of Defense child care centers failed safety codes and that rules and staff training were inadequate. The Military Child Care Act of 1989 required training before staff worked with children, raised pay, and set fees by family income, and Congress funded the changes. By 2002 Education Week reported that yearly staff turnover had fallen from as high as 300% to about 30%, that nearly all of the roughly 800 centers serving more than 170,000 children were accredited by the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC), and that jobs once paid under $1 an hour in some places averaged more than $10 an hour.

    Lessonthe law came with money for higher pay as well as rules for training and inspection.

    edweek.orghechingerreport.org

    Credit

    US Congress; US Department of Defense

  2. 1999

    Ratios linked to outcomes

    Researchers in the US Study of Early Child Care checked classes in child care centers against four recommended standards: child-to-staff ratio, group size, caregiver training and caregiver education. Few classes met all four, from 10% of classes at 6 months of age to 34% at 36 months. Children in classes that met more standards had better school-readiness and language scores and fewer behavior problems at 36 months; the ratio predicted outcomes at 24 months, and caregiver training and education at 36 months. The study observed these links; it did not assign children to classes.

    eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    the Early Child Care Research Network of the US National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD)

  3. 2009

    New Zealand cuts its target

    New Zealand's 2002 ten-year plan, Pathways to the Future, aimed for every teacher in teacher-led early childhood services to be qualified and registered, and funded services at higher rates when more of their teachers were. By 2008 just over 60% were, ahead of the 50% target for 2007. The government elected in 2008 cut the target from 100% to 80% in 2009, and in February 2011 replaced the higher funding rates with one flat rate for services with 80% or more. A teachers' union survey after the 2016 budget found services coping through pay cuts, more untrained staff and less time with qualified teachers.

    Lessonthe qualification target lasted only as long as the funding that paid for it.

    ojs.victoria.ac.nz

    Credit

    New Zealand Ministry of Education; review by Claire McLachlan, Sue Cherrington, Karyn Aspden and Tara McLaughlin

  4. 2014

    Community mothers become employees

    In Colombia's community homes program, run by the Colombian Family Welfare Institute (ICBF), madres comunitarias, community mothers, look after groups of young children, often in the carer's own house. Article 36 of Law 1607 of 2012 ordered that they be formally employed, and Decree 289 of 2014 set it up: labor contracts with the organizations that run the program, with the rights of the labor code and pay of the legal monthly minimum wage, but not as public servants. ICBF counted 40,045 community mothers in the 2022 to 2026 government term, 46.6% of them with more than 10 years' experience.

    LessonICBF itself says that pay fixed at the minimum wage, with no career path, works against keeping experienced carers.

    icbf.gov.co

    Credit

    Congress and government of Colombia; ICBF and the Ministry of Labor

  5. 2021

    A second worker doubles teaching

    India's Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) serves over 36 million children aged 3 to 6 through 1.35 million anganwadi (village child care) centers, each run by one worker who also handles health, nutrition, home visits and paperwork; in Tamil Nadu workers spent 38 minutes a day on preschool teaching out of a scheduled two hours. The state government added a half-time preschool facilitator, paid half a regular worker's salary, to half of 320 centers, chosen at random. Teaching time doubled to 76 minutes a day, and after 18 months children at those centers scored 0.29, 0.46 and 0.18 standard deviations higher in mathematics, language and executive function (a standard deviation is the typical spread of scores among children), with less stunting.

    nber.org

    Credit

    Alejandro Ganimian, Karthik Muralidharan and Christopher Walters; Government of Tamil Nadu

  6. 2023

    England loosens two-year-old ratios

    England's minimum ratio for two-year-olds in group settings changed from one adult to four children to one adult to five from September 2023, matching Scotland. Most of the 14,043 responses to the government's consultation disagreed. In a government-commissioned survey, 70% of group settings with two-year-olds said they would be unlikely to change their provision, and the department estimated that only 7% to 12% of such settings would pass any savings on to parents. The ratio for under-twos stayed at one to three, and for children aged three and over at one to eight.

    assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK Department for Education

  7. 2024

    Japan tightens a 1948 ratio

    Japan's minimum standards for child welfare facilities, set by a 1948 ordinance, allowed one nursery worker for every 30 children aged four and five, a ratio not improved in 75 years. Under the Children's Future Strategy adopted by the Cabinet in December 2023, from fiscal year 2024 the minimum became 1 to 25 for four- and five-year-olds and 1 to 15 for three-year-olds (from 1 to 20), with extra payments for nurseries that meet it; existing facilities may keep the old ratio for the time being. The plan also aims to move one-year-olds from 1 to 6 to 1 to 5 from fiscal year 2025 onward.

    city.kobe.lg.jpisvd.or.jp

    Credit

    Government of Japan

Watch for

  1. Australia's 15% pay rise

    Australia's government pays for a 15% wage rise above the award (the legal minimum pay rates) for early childhood workers, 10% from December 2024 and 5% more from December 2025, at services that agreed to limit fee rises, starting with a cap of 4.4% for August 2024 to August 2025; it committed a further AUD 3.6 billion on 17 June 2026 to continue it. In its response to an inquiry, the government said that since the payment was announced there were about 20,000 more workers (about 8% more), job vacancies were down about 30%, the share of services with a staffing waiver had fallen from 8.9% to 4.3%, and fees at services in the scheme had grown at half the rate of others.

    Achieved whenan independent evaluation, using national workforce data, shows how much of the change is due to the payment rather than other trends.

    thesector.com.aupm.gov.au

    Claimed by

    Australian Government, November 2026

  2. AI schedules that keep ratios

    Legion, a workforce software company, says its AI "auto-generates schedules that maintain ratios without overspending", enforces staff-to-child ratios in real time, and cuts the time spent on scheduling by 50%. It names KinderCare, a US child care chain, as a customer, and gives no method or baseline for the 50%.

    Achieved whena customer's audited records or an outside study report ratio breaches and scheduling hours before and after adoption.

    legion.colegion.co

    Claimed by

    Legion, June 2025

  3. Colombia hires carers directly

    From 2026 Colombia is moving community mothers from employment by the organizations that run the program to direct employment by ICBF as official workers, under Article 68 of Law 2466 of 2025. ICBF says it has created 2,353 such posts at a cost of COP 91,282 million, and that direct employment gives steadier pay that will help keep carers and the children's bonds with them.

    Achieved whenICBF or an outside evaluator reports how many community mothers moved to direct contracts and whether turnover fell.

    icbf.gov.co

    Claimed by

    ICBF, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Preschool ratio rules worldwide

    An open, machine-readable table of the legal minimum staff-to-child ratios and maximum group sizes for children from age three to school entry, in centers and preschools, for at least 40 countries outside Europe (including Asia, Africa and Latin America), each row linked to the clause of the regulation it comes from and stated in one unit, children per adult, and joined to the World Bank's existing figures for children under three.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A test for ratio rosters

    An open benchmark of 200 made-up center days, each listing children's ages and arrival and leaving times in 15-minute blocks and staff shifts, breaks and qualifications, with a reference solver that works out the fewest staff needed in each block under three rule sets (for example England, Japan and one US state). A test harness then scores any scheduling tool or AI agent on minutes out of ratio and staff hours above the minimum. No real children's data is used.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Preschool ratio rules worldwide

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, machine-readable table of the legal minimum staff-to-child ratios and maximum group sizes for children from age three to school entry, in centers and preschools, for at least 40 countries outside Europe (including Asia, Africa and Latin America), each row linked to the clause of the regulation it comes from and stated in one unit, children per adult, and joined to the World Bank's existing figures for children under three.

Why it is still open

The World Bank's Women, Business and the Law 2024 records whether the law sets caregiver-to-child ratios and group sizes in 190 economies, and charts the ratios themselves, but only for center-based care of children under three; in Latin America and the Caribbean it found ratios set in law in 20 economies. Other comparisons are reports in PDF form covering a few rich countries: a 2013 UK Department for Education report tabulates 15 OECD countries, and an April 2026 Fondazione Agnelli paper compares five European countries. The US National Database of Child Care Licensing Regulations is a search tool for state rules, US only. Searches found no clause-linked table for ages three to five outside Europe.

wbl.worldbank.orgassets.publishing.service.gov.ukfondazioneagnelli.itlicensingregulations.acf.hhs.gov

Built with what exists

A browser agent such as Browser Use 1.0 to find and download regulations (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a long-context AI model to pull ratios from the text, including Spanish, Portuguese, French and Japanese; two people to check each row against the clause; CSV on a public repository.

  1. First step

    Fix the table's columns and fill rows for England and Japan, whose ratios for three- to five-year-olds are cited on this page, then for the 20 Latin American and Caribbean economies the World Bank lists.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 40 countries, every row with a link and a quoted clause; an audit of 100 random rows by a second person finds fewer than 2 errors; the World Bank's under-three figures joined where they exist; versioned releases with the date each rule was read.

Open 02 · the brief

A test for ratio rosters

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open benchmark of 200 made-up center days, each listing children's ages and arrival and leaving times in 15-minute blocks and staff shifts, breaks and qualifications, with a reference solver that works out the fewest staff needed in each block under three rule sets (for example England, Japan and one US state). A test harness then scores any scheduling tool or AI agent on minutes out of ratio and staff hours above the minimum. No real children's data is used.

Why it is still open

Legion sells AI scheduling that it says keeps ratios, with no outside test. Public ratio calculators, such as Wisconsin's, work out the staff needed for one group at one moment, not a day's roster with arrivals, departures and breaks. A 2018 study built a shift scheduler for one Japanese nursery school with integer programming, a standard optimization method, and found its rosters better than hand-made ones; its abstract describes staff requests and shift patterns, not ratios, and it published no test cases. Searches found rostering research for nurses but no shared test for child care rosters.

legion.codcf.wisconsin.govjstage.jst.go.jp

Built with what exists

Google's open-source OR-Tools constraint solver for the reference answers; Python to generate the made-up days; an AI agent built on a low-cost model such as Meta's Muse Ember for the routine tool calls (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat").

  1. First step

    Write a generator for 20 made-up days at a 60-child center and encode England's ratios in the solver.

  2. Done looks like

    200 days with checked reference answers for three rule sets; scores published for at least three tools, including one AI agent, as minutes out of ratio per day and extra staff hours over the minimum.