Industries / Finance and business services / Payroll / Benefits administration
Compliance
Compliance is the work of meeting the law's duties for benefit plans: acting in members' interest, filing annual reports, giving mental health care the same terms as other care, and keeping members' data safe.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1974 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1974
A law for benefit plans
President Gerald R. Ford signed the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) on 2 September 1974. It set rules for private benefit plans on reporting and disclosure, funding, vesting and fiduciary duties (the duties of the people who run a plan to act in its members' interest), and it established the PBGC.
Credit
US Congress; President Gerald R. Ford; Senator Jacob Javits, who introduced pension reform legislation in 1967
2010
Annual reports go online
US benefit plans file an annual report, the Form 5500, which the Labor Department calls the primary source of plan financial information for the government, participants, researchers and the public. Filings made on or after 1 January 2010 had to go through the all-electronic EFAST2 system, after two deferrals since the department first proposed it in 2005; the department expected over 1 million filings a year, generally available within a day of receipt, and estimated that keeping a paper option would cost more than twice as much to build and run.
Credit
US Department of Labor, with the IRS and the PBGC
2015
A duty to keep checking
On 18 May 2015, in Tibble v. Edison International, a unanimous US Supreme Court held that under trust law a fiduciary "has a continuing duty to monitor trust investments and remove imprudent ones", separate from the duty to choose prudently at the outset, and sent the case back to the lower court.
LessonChoosing a plan's funds carefully once is not enough; the funds must be reviewed for as long as they are offered.
Credit
Justice Stephen Breyer, for a unanimous Court; the Edison employees who brought the case
2022
Parity proofs fall short
US health plans must not limit mental health and substance use care more strictly than medical care, including through limits that are not numbers, such as prior authorization (nonquantitative treatment limitations, or NQTLs), and from February 2021 a new law required plans to have written comparative analyses showing this. In 2021 the Labor Department sent 156 letters asking plans and insurers for analyses of 216 distinct NQTLs across 86 investigations, and its 2022 report to Congress said "none of the comparative analyses reviewed to date have contained sufficient information upon initial receipt"; many plans had not started theirs by the deadline. Common faults included "conclusory assertions lacking specific supporting evidence" and failure to show how a limit worked in practice.
LessonA duty to document compliance revealed that most plans could not show it.
Credit
US Department of Labor, with HHS and the Treasury
2023
A vendor leaks retiree data
The Record reported on 22 June 2023 that CalPERS, the California Public Employees' Retirement System, had been told on 6 June by its vendor PBI Research Services/Berwyn Group, which identifies the deaths of beneficiaries to prevent overpayments and verifies details of inactive members, that attackers had used a flaw in the MOVEit file-transfer software to download member data: names, dates of birth and Social Security numbers, and possibly the names of employers, spouses or domestic partners and children.
LessonA plan's data is only as safe as every vendor that holds a copy, including those doing routine checks.
Credit
Reporting by Jonathan Greig, The Record
2025
Parity rule paused
In May 2025 the Labor Department, HHS and the Treasury said they would not enforce the parts of their 2024 parity rule that are new compared with the 2013 rule, and would reconsider the 2024 rule, including whether to propose rescinding or modifying it, as the International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans reported on 16 May 2025.
LessonA new benefits rule can be paused before it is enforced, so administrators have to track enforcement as well as the text.
Credit
The Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services and the Treasury
Watch for
A safe harbor for funds
On 30 March 2026 the US Labor Department proposed a process-based safe harbor for choosing the investment options in 401(k) plans, including those with private-market assets: a fiduciary who weighs six factors (performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, benchmark and complexity) would be presumed to have acted prudently and be "entitled to significant deference". The proposal, published in the Federal Register on 31 March 2026, answers an August 2025 executive order, "Democratizing Access to Alternative Assets for 401(k) Investors"; comments were due on 1 June 2026, by Morgan Lewis's account.
Achieved whenA final rule takes effect and courts apply its presumption in cases over plan investments.
Claimed by
US Department of Labor, March 2026
Open
01
Testing AI parity reviewers
A public test of AI reviewers for mental health parity: at least 100 invented plan documents with comparative analyses, each with seeded faults of the kinds regulators report (for example a prior-authorization rule applied only to mental health care, or an analysis that names no factors), and the list of right answers, so that reviewers can be scored on what they find and what they flag wrongly.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Form 1095-C, answer key
A public answer key for lines 14 and 16 of Form 1095-C, where applicable large employers report, for each full-time employee and month, what cover was offered and which safe harbor applies: at least 300 invented employee-years (offers, enrollments, hires, terminations, waiting periods, affordability safe harbors), each with the correct codes and the instruction they rest on. Score payroll and benefits software and AI models against it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Testing AI parity reviewers
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test of AI reviewers for mental health parity: at least 100 invented plan documents with comparative analyses, each with seeded faults of the kinds regulators report (for example a prior-authorization rule applied only to mental health care, or an analysis that names no factors), and the list of right answers, so that reviewers can be scored on what they find and what they flag wrongly.
Why it is still open
The Labor Department found that none of the analyses it first reviewed contained enough information. Nathaniel Counts' study in Psychiatric Services, as reported by the Kennedy Forum in March 2026, found that an AI model flagged on average 3.8 areas of possible noncompliance per document, and that 49% of its flags were correct (its positive predictive value). This research found no public test set with known answers on which such reviewers could be compared.
Built with what exists
The deficiency list in the Labor Department's 2022 report; AI models such as Claude Opus 5.5 as reviewers under test, with a second pass that lists what a person should check, as in the Note "Seven more flagged"; Python for scoring.
First step
Write 10 plan documents, each with one fault from the report's list ("conclusory assertions lacking specific supporting evidence", "failure to identify all factors", "failure to demonstrate compliance of an NQTL as applied"), and run one model on them.
Done looks like
100 documents with at least 300 seeded faults, each answer checked by two reviewers; at least three AI reviewers scored on the share of faults found and the share of flags that are correct; all of it public.
Open 02 · the brief
Form 1095-C, answer key
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public answer key for lines 14 and 16 of Form 1095-C, where applicable large employers report, for each full-time employee and month, what cover was offered and which safe harbor applies: at least 300 invented employee-years (offers, enrollments, hires, terminations, waiting periods, affordability safe harbors), each with the correct codes and the instruction they rest on. Score payroll and benefits software and AI models against it.
Why it is still open
Applicable large employers must file Forms 1094-C and 1095-C with the IRS each year and give each full-time employee a 1095-C by 31 January. The 2025 IRS instructions set out "Code Series 1—Offer of Coverage" and "Code Series 2—Section 4980H Safe Harbor Codes and Other Relief for ALE Members". A search for this research found vendor code sheets and commercial software but no public answer key.
Built with what exists
The IRS instructions; Python; the full-time answer key under Eligibility, since a month's codes depend on the employee's status; an AI coding agent checked only against the key (see the Note "Code no person read").
First step
Write 20 employee-years for common cases (offered and enrolled all year; hired mid-year with a waiting period; terminated mid-year) and work out their codes from the instructions by hand.
Done looks like
At least 300 employee-years, each code citing its instruction and signed off by two reviewers, released under an open license; scores for at least three systems, with every disagreement explained.