BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Staffing and recruiting / Background checks

Consent and law

The rules on when a check may be run, what the person must be told and agree to, and how results such as criminal records may be used to turn someone down.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1982 to 2023.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1982

    Convictions must relate to work

    Quebec's Charter of human rights and freedoms has since 1982 barred employers from penalizing a person for an offense that "was in no way connected with the employment", and British Columbia's Human Rights Code bars refusing someone work because of a conviction "that is unrelated to the employment". In the US, New York State's Correction Law Article 23-A has protected people with conviction records since 1977, by the account of New York City's Commission on Human Rights.

    legisquebec.gouv.qc.cabclaws.gov.bc.canyc.gov

    Credit

    National Assembly of Quebec; Legislative Assembly of British Columbia; New York State Legislature

  2. 1996

    Disclose, get consent, then warn

    The Consumer Credit Reporting Reform Act of 1996, in force from 30 September 1997, requires a US employer to tell an applicant in writing, "in a document that consists solely of the disclosure", that it may order a report, and to get written permission. Before acting against the person because of the report, the employer must give them a copy of it and a written summary of their rights. FTC staff added in 2011 that the form may not include a waiver of the person's rights or be part of a printed job application.

    govinfo.govftc.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; FTC staff

  3. 1998

    Ask only after an offer

    Hawaii's 1998 law lets employers ask about convictions only after a conditional job offer, and use only convictions that bear "a rational relationship" to the job, looking back seven years for felonies and five for misdemeanors, not counting time in prison. Such fair-chance or "ban the box" laws have spread: NELP counts 37 states, the District of Columbia and over 150 cities and counties, with 15 states covering private employers. The federal Fair Chance to Compete for Jobs Act, signed on 20 December 2019, covers most federal agencies and contractors, and California's Fair Chance Act, in force since 1 January 2018, requires an individualized assessment of each conviction.

    data.capitol.hawaii.govnelp.orggovinfo.govcalcivilrights.ca.govleginfo.legislature.ca.gov

    Credit

    Hawaii State Legislature; All of Us or None, the campaign NELP credits with the idea; NELP; US Congress; California Legislature

  4. 2012

    Guidance used, then rescinded

    The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) told employers in April 2012 that excluding everyone with a criminal record could amount to race discrimination under federal law, and that screens should weigh the offense, the time since it happened and the job, three factors taken from a 1975 court case, with a chance for the person to explain. It brought cases on that basis: BMW paid $1.6 million in 2015 and Dollar General $6 million in 2019. On 28 October 2026 the Commission voted to rescind the guidance, effective immediately.

    Lessonguidance can be withdrawn by a vote, while laws such as California's, which write the same three factors into statute, remain.

    eeoc.goveeoc.goveeoc.goveeoc.gov

    Credit

    US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission

  5. 2017

    No waivers in disclosures

    On 20 January 2017 the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held, in Syed v. M-I, that an employer that put a waiver of liability into its FCRA disclosure broke the rule that the document consist "solely" of the disclosure. It held the violation willful, which exposes an employer to statutory damages of $100 to $1,000 per violation, and called the question one of first impression among the federal appeals courts.

    LessonFTC staff had warned against waivers in 2011, so the employer could not call the mistake an honest reading of the law.

    cdn.ca9.uscourts.govcdn.ca9.uscourts.gov

    Credit

    US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (opinion by Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw)

  6. 2018

    Europe restricts conviction data

    Under Article 10 of the EU's General Data Protection Regulation, which applies from 25 May 2018, data about criminal convictions may be processed only under the control of official authority or where EU or national law allows it with safeguards. In France only the convicted person can request bulletin no. 3, the extract of the criminal record used for jobs, and an employer may look at it but may not keep it. In Germany the certificate of conduct (Führungszeugnis) may be sent only to the person who applied for it. The UK's Data Protection Act 2018 lists the conditions, such as duties in employment backed by a written policy, under which such data may be used.

    legislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.ukservice-public.frgesetze-im-internet.deico.org.uk

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council of the EU; French and German governments; UK Parliament

  7. 2023

    Landlords' question ban struck

    Seattle's Fair Chance Housing Ordinance of 2017 barred landlords from asking about or acting on most criminal history. On 21 March 2023 the Ninth Circuit held that the ban on asking violates the First Amendment's protection of speech, while upholding the ban on acting on records, and in August 2025 it confirmed that the rest of the ordinance stands without the provision on asking.

    Lessonin the US a rule on what a landlord may decide can survive where a rule on what a landlord may ask falls as a limit on speech.

    cdn.ca9.uscourts.govcdn.ca9.uscourts.gov

    Credit

    US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit; Seattle City Council

Watch for

  1. State ban meets federal rule

    Utah's SB 70, in force from 7 May 2025, bars screening companies from reporting arrests or charges that did not end in conviction, and convictions that were expunged or pardoned. The CFPB's interpretive rule of 28 October 2025 says state laws that regulate which categories of information appear in reports are not valid.

    Achieved whenA court rules on whether federal law overrides SB 70 or a similar state ban, or Utah enforces it.

    le.utah.govgovinfo.gov

    Claimed by

    Utah Legislature (sponsors Senator Stephanie Pitcher and Representative Jordan Teuscher), May 2025

  2. California's rules for automated decisions

    California's Civil Rights Council rules applying the state's anti-discrimination law to automated-decision systems used in employment were approved on 27 June 2025 and took effect on 1 October 2025. Screening tools that use criminal history fall under the state's Fair Chance Act, but the announcement does not say how the two sets of rules interact.

    Achieved whenThe Civil Rights Department or a court applies the rules to an automated tool that screens criminal history.

    calcivilrights.ca.govcalcivilrights.ca.gov

    Claimed by

    California Civil Rights Council, June 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Fair-chance laws as tested code

    Machine-readable rules for US fair-chance laws in states, cities and counties: when an employer may ask about records, how far back it may look, whether an individual assessment is required, what notices must say, and how long the person has to respond (at least five business days in New York City). Each field cites the law, and test cases of made-up applicants check that the rules decide correctly. It describes the law and gives no advice to anyone.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Test AI on screening law

    Questions with dated answer keys that quote the law itself, on consent, disclosure and adverse action in several countries: the FCRA's employment sections, the Hawaii and California fair-chance laws, the UK's Rehabilitation of Offenders Act and DBS filtering rules, GDPR Article 10, Germany's rule on certificates of conduct, France's bulletin no. 3, and the Quebec and British Columbia human rights laws. Score AI models on them.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Fair-chance laws as tested code

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Machine-readable rules for US fair-chance laws in states, cities and counties: when an employer may ask about records, how far back it may look, whether an individual assessment is required, what notices must say, and how long the person has to respond (at least five business days in New York City). Each field cites the law, and test cases of made-up applicants check that the rules decide correctly. It describes the law and gives no advice to anyone.

Why it is still open

The closest structured dataset, Temple University's LawAtlas set on ban-the-box laws, covers state laws only, as of 1 January 2021. NELP's guide to state and local laws is a document, not data, and its own pages disagree on the number of local laws ("over 150" and "nearly 200" cities and counties).

lawatlas.orgnelp.orgnelp.org

Built with what exists

Catala, a programming language for writing laws as code, or OpenFisca; JSON Schema with pytest run in GitHub Actions; Browser Use 1.0 to collect local ordinances (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over").

github.com

  1. First step

    Encode Hawaii, California and New York City with 30 made-up cases.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 15 jurisdictions encoded, each field citing a section and link, at least 10 made-up test cases per jurisdiction passing in automated checks, and a published comparison with NELP's list.

Open 02 · the brief

Test AI on screening law

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Questions with dated answer keys that quote the law itself, on consent, disclosure and adverse action in several countries: the FCRA's employment sections, the Hawaii and California fair-chance laws, the UK's Rehabilitation of Offenders Act and DBS filtering rules, GDPR Article 10, Germany's rule on certificates of conduct, France's bulletin no. 3, and the Quebec and British Columbia human rights laws. Score AI models on them.

Why it is still open

LegalBench, an open benchmark of 162 legal reasoning tasks, has no task on the FCRA, fair-chance laws or criminal record checks, by this research's check of its task list. The reversals of 2025 and 2026 also mean that answers need an "as of" date.

arxiv.org

Built with what exists

Inspect, the UK AI Security Institute's open framework for testing AI models; LegalBench's task format; current AI models, including one that scores fixed-answer questions, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); two reviewers with legal training to check the keys.

  1. First step

    Write 25 questions from section 604 of the FCRA and the DBS filtering rules.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 200 questions across at least five jurisdictions, each with a quoted source and link, the reviewers' agreement reported, and scores for at least three models.