BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Software and SaaS / Ad and marketing tech

Marketing automation

Software that sends emails, texts and app or browser notifications to customers on a schedule, or in response to something they did, such as signing up.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2002 to 2022.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2002

    Consent before marketing email

    The European Union's ePrivacy Directive (2002/58/EC) of 12 July 2002 allowed marketing by email, fax or automated calls only to people "who have given their prior consent". It made one exception, often called the soft opt-in: a company may email its own customers about its "similar products or services" if every message offers a free and easy way to object. Member states had to bring it into force before 31 October 2003. The US chose another route. Its CAN-SPAM Act, signed on 16 December 2003 and in force from 1 January 2004, needs no prior consent, but a marketing email must say it is an advertisement (unless the recipient agreed beforehand), offer an opt-out and give the sender's postal address.

    LessonSending software has had to apply two rule sets from the start, consent first in Europe and opt-out in the US.

    legislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.ukgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    the European Parliament and Council of the EU; the US Congress

  2. 2011

    One breach, many brands

    On 1 April 2011 Epsilon Data Management, a Texas firm that sent marketing email on behalf of other companies, announced that someone had broken into its email system on 30 March and taken customer names and email addresses. Epsilon said it sent more than 40 billion emails a year for more than 2,500 clients. Clients reported as affected included Best Buy, Capital One, Citi, JPMorgan Chase, Kroger, Marriott Rewards, TiVo and Walgreens. Connecticut's attorney general and consumer protection commissioner warned that scammers could now send convincing fake emails in those brands' names.

    LessonA shared sending service holds many companies' lists in one place, so a single break-in gave phishers ready-made lists for dozens of brands at once.

    hunton.comportal.ct.gov

    Credit

    Epsilon Data Management (the breached firm); Connecticut Attorney General George Jepsen and Commissioner William Rubenstein for the warning

  3. 2012

    Proof of who sent it

    DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance) lets the owner of a web domain publish a rule that tells mailbox providers what to do with mail that claims to come from that domain but fails the existing checks, called SPF and DKIM, and asks the providers to send back reports. Mailbox providers (AOL, Comcast, Gmail, Hotmail, Netease and Yahoo Mail), senders (among them Bank of America, Facebook, LinkedIn and PayPal) and vendors published the specification on 30 January 2012. It appeared as RFC 7489, an informational document, in March 2015. The Internet Engineering Task Force published DMARC as a Proposed Standard, RFC 9989, in May 2026, replacing RFC 7489.

    LessonThe rule worked for 14 years as an informal agreement among large mail services before it became a formal standard.

    dmarc.orgrfc-editor.orgrfc-editor.org

    Credit

    DMARC.org's founding contributors; editors M. Kucherawy and E. Zwicky (RFC 7489), T. Herr and J. Levine (RFC 9989)

  4. 2014

    Canada requires consent

    Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) came into force on 1 July 2014. It requires a business to have a person's consent before sending them commercial electronic messages such as email, to identify itself in each message and to offer a way to unsubscribe. According to Global News, businesses face penalties of up to C$10 million per violation. On 5 March 2015 the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC), which enforces the law, issued its first fine: C$1.1 million to Compu-Finder, a Quebec company that, the CRTC said, kept emailing addresses "it found by scouring websites" and did not let people unsubscribe.

    globalnews.ca

    Credit

    the Parliament of Canada; the CRTC

  5. 2020

    Browsers curb push prompts

    Web push notifications let a website send messages to a visitor's screen after the visitor clicks "Allow", and many sites asked on the first visit. Mozilla measured that about 99% of these prompts went unaccepted in Firefox. In one month of Firefox 63, 1.45 billion prompts were shown and 23.66 million accepted. In November 2019 Mozilla said that from Firefox 72 a site could ask only after the visitor clicked, tapped or pressed a key. On 7 January 2020 Google said Chrome 80 would show a quieter prompt to people who usually block these requests and on sites with very low acceptance rates.

    LessonAsking at the wrong moment cost senders the channel; in Mozilla's Nightly test, 52% of prompts shown after a click were accepted the first time.

    blog.mozilla.orgblog.chromium.org

    Credit

    Mozilla (analysis by Felix Lawrence); Google Chrome

  6. 2022

    Marketing email gets audited

    The Email Markup Consortium began testing real HTML emails, collected from senders in many industries and languages, with Parcel's accessibility checker, a tool built for testing email. It sorts each fault on the four-level scale used by Deque's axe tools. Its first report, on 35,604 HTML emails collected between May and July 2022, found that 99.9% had faults rated "Serious" or "Critical". In its 2026 report, 99.88% of 376,348 emails collected from May 2025 to May 2026 still did. Only 8 emails, from 3 brands, passed every check, and none of 10,566 emails sent through Substack, Shopify and Beehiiv did. Common faults include a missing language setting, which screen readers need to pronounce the text, and images used as links with no text description.

    LessonIn the consortium's words the faults are "basic, machine-checkable", and it blames builder tools that put layout ahead of structure and do not show settings such as language.

    emailmarkup.orgemailmarkup.org

    Credit

    Email Markup Consortium, with Parcel

Watch for

  1. Agents run whole campaigns

    Klaviyo says its Marketing Agent, unveiled on 25 September 2025, "autonomously plans and launches campaigns in minutes": given a shop's web address, it returns "a complete marketing plan with ready-to-send campaigns, flows, and forms", flows being automated message sequences. On 23 April 2026 Braze made its BrazeAI Operator and Agent Console generally available, to bring "decisioning, content generation, and execution" into the marketer's workflow. Neither release reports a measured result.

    Achieved whensomeone outside the vendors runs agent-built and person-built campaigns side by side for the same brands and publishes sales, unsubscribe and spam-complaint rates for both.

    s25.q4cdn.combraze.com

    Claimed by

    Klaviyo, September 2025; Braze, April 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Score AI email builders

    A public test of the AI tools that now write and lay out marketing emails. Give each tool the same 25 briefs for made-up shops, export the emails it produces, and run them through the automated accessibility checks the Email Markup Consortium uses, with a person reviewing the alt text (the description read aloud in place of an image).

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Repair email code before sending

    An open-source step that runs just before an email goes out and fixes the machine-checkable faults the consortium finds most often. It adds the language setting, marks layout tables as layout so screen readers skip them, and drafts text descriptions for linked images for a person to approve. The email must look the same afterwards.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score AI email builders

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of the AI tools that now write and lay out marketing emails. Give each tool the same 25 briefs for made-up shops, export the emails it produces, and run them through the automated accessibility checks the Email Markup Consortium uses, with a person reviewing the alt text (the description read aloud in place of an image).

Why it is still open

The consortium's 2026 report tested emails as brands and three newsletter platforms sent them, and found 99.88% failing, but it did not test what AI builders produce on their own. Klaviyo says its agent writes "ready-to-send campaigns". Stensul's in-builder check, launched in May 2026, flags faults such as missing alt text but publishes no pass rate. Searches found no published audit of AI-written marketing emails.

emailmarkup.orgs25.q4cdn.comstensul.com

Built with what exists

free or trial accounts on email platforms with AI builders, such as Klaviyo's Marketing Agent; Parcel's accessibility checker, which the consortium says is free on Parcel's Community plan, or Intopia's open-source HTML email accessibility tester; a sending domain and test inboxes the tester owns, so no real customer receives anything; a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Write the 25 briefs for fictional shops and generate the first 5 emails in one tool's free trial.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 5 AI builders, 25 emails each, with the share passing all serious and critical checks, the count of each fault, and the emails published; plus 25 emails built by hand in each tool's normal editor for comparison.

Open 02 · the brief

Repair email code before sending

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open-source step that runs just before an email goes out and fixes the machine-checkable faults the consortium finds most often. It adds the language setting, marks layout tables as layout so screen readers skip them, and drafts text descriptions for linked images for a person to approve. The email must look the same afterwards.

Why it is still open

Checkers exist, among them Parcel's, Intopia's tester and a Visual Studio Code extension for MJML, a common email coding language, but they report faults rather than fix them. The consortium says platforms "often fail to expose critical accessibility fields like language settings" to senders. Searches of GitHub and the web found no open tool that rewrites the code and publishes before-and-after pass rates.

emailmarkup.orggithub.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

Python or Node.js with an HTML parser; an AI model that can read images to draft descriptions, each approved by a person; Parcel's checker or Intopia's tester to score results; screenshots from a headless browser and from a few mail apps on test inboxes, compared pixel by pixel.

  1. First step

    Collect 100 marketing emails in a test inbox, run the checker on them, and write fixes for the three most common faults.

  2. Done looks like

    On 1,000 marketing emails collected by subscribing test inboxes to brands' newsletters, the share passing all serious and critical checks rises from under 1% to at least 50%, with before-and-after screenshots differing by less than 1% of pixels, and the code and results published.