Industries / Technology / Software and SaaS / Ad and marketing tech
Ad auctions
Ad auctions are the software that decides, while a web page or app loads, which advertiser's ad fills each space and at what price.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1997 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1997
Ad serving for rent
An ad server is software that picks which ad goes into a space on a page, delivers it and counts it. DoubleClick, incorporated in January 1996, began its DART for Publishers service in January 1997: a website could rent ad selection, targeting and reporting run from DoubleClick's data centres instead of building its own. By DoubleClick's own count in its annual report, its DART technology served 621 billion ads in 2000.
Credit
DoubleClick
2008
Google buys the leader
In 2008 Google paid $3.1 billion for DoubleClick. A US federal court later found that DoubleClick for Publishers (DFP), its ad server, then had a 60% share of publisher ad serving and counted nine of the ten largest US websites as customers, and that Google bought it partly to keep it from Microsoft. The court found the purchase itself was not anticompetitive when it was made. Google then joined DFP to its own ad exchange, AdX, and to AdWords, its tool for advertisers.
LessonThe court ruled against the rules Google later built into the joined products, not against the purchase, so the auction's code mattered more than the deal.
Credit
Google; findings by Judge Leonie Brinkema of the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, April 2025
2015
Header bidding spreads
In header bidding, code in the top section (the header) of a web page asks several ad exchanges for bids at once, before the publisher's ad server makes its choice. Publishers used it to get around First Look, a DFP rule that let AdX take an ad space if its bid met the publisher's minimum price, before rival bids were looked at. In the court's example, AdX's $1.07 per thousand views could win while other exchanges offered $1.08 and $1.10. The court found that header bidding "achieved widespread adoption by large publishers in 2015". Prebid.js, open-source code for running these auctions, launched in 2015; Prebid calls it "the most widely used header bidding 'container' or 'wrapper' on the web".
Credit
Prebid, described by the court as "non-Google industry members and open-source advocates"
2019
One first-price auction
In a second-price auction the winner pays about the runner-up's bid; in a first-price auction it pays what it bid. On 6 March 2019 Google said Ad Manager would move to "a unified first price auction" in which "an advertising buyer's bid will not be shared with another buyer before the auction", and it began the switch for all partners in September 2019. With the change Google dropped Last Look, which the court found had let AdX see the winning header-bidding bid and then beat it; in an expert's words quoted by the court, AdX could "just bid 1 cent more". At the same time Google brought in Unified Pricing Rules, which stopped publishers from setting a higher minimum price for AdX than for rival exchanges.
LessonThe court found that many publishers had set higher minimums for AdX to depend less on Google, so the new rule took away one of the few tools they had.
Credit
Google
2021
A regulator examines auctions
On 7 June 2021 France's competition authority, the Autorité de la concurrence, fined Google €220 million for favouring its own ad tech. It found that DFP had told AdX the prices offered by rival exchanges, and that AdX used them to adjust its bids and its commission. Google did not dispute the facts, settled, and accepted binding commitments to make its tools work with rival ad servers and exchanges. The authority's president, Isabelle de Silva, called it "the first decision in the world to look into complex algorithmic auctions processes through which online display advertising works."
Credit
Autorité de la concurrence, on complaints from News Corp and the Rossel La Voix group (Le Figaro withdrew its complaint)
2025
Europe fines €2.95 billion
On 5 September 2025 the European Commission fined Google €2.95 billion. It found that since at least 2014 Google had favoured AdX, for example by "informing AdX in advance of the value of the best bid from competitors which it had to beat to win the auction", and that Google Ads had mainly bid on AdX. It ordered Google to stop and said its preliminary view was that "only the divestment by Google of part of its services" would end Google's conflicts of interest.
LessonThree authorities, in France in 2021 and in the US and the EU in 2025, found the same fault: the company running the auction also bid in it and saw rival bids first.
Credit
European Commission
Watch for
An auction that proves fairness
The Trade Desk, whose software buys ads for advertisers, launched OpenAds in October 2025: a wrapper, a layer of code around an auction, built on Prebid. It says that in OpenAds "the highest bid will win", whether the bid comes from The Trade Desk or another buyer, that the auction's mechanics "will be published and auditable", and that publishers will be able to check what code is running. Beta tests were to start in November 2025. On 20 November 2026 The Trade Desk's public GitHub account held no OpenAds code (this page's check).
Achieved whenthe auction code is public and an independent auditor confirms, on live auctions, that the highest bid won.
Claimed by
The Trade Desk, October 2025
Europe's fix without a sale
After the €2.95 billion fine, Google filed a compliance plan in November 2025 that proposes changes to how its tools work instead of selling any of them. The Commission gave itself more time in March 2026 and, as of September 2026, was still assessing the plan, while Google appealed the decision at the EU's General Court.
Achieved whenthe Commission rules that the changes end Google's conflicts of interest, or orders its own remedy, and the changes are in force.
Claimed by
Google, November 2025
Open
01
A public header bidding record
A monthly public dataset, made by an automated browser that visits the 10,000 most-visited websites, that records for each header-bidding auction which exchanges were asked, the time limit the site set, how long each bid took, and how long the page waited before asking its ad server for an ad.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Final-auction test suite
An open-source reference version of a publisher ad server's "final auction", the last step that weighs direct deals, the header-bidding winner and exchange bids and picks one ad, plus a public set of test cases with known right answers that any ad server, run in test mode, can be checked against.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
A public header bidding record
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A monthly public dataset, made by an automated browser that visits the 10,000 most-visited websites, that records for each header-bidding auction which exchanges were asked, the time limit the site set, how long each bid took, and how long the page waited before asking its ad server for an ad.
Why it is still open
The best-known measurement, by Michalis Pachilakis and colleagues, crawled 35,000 sites once, in 2019, and collected 800,000 auctions; it found header bidding could be slower than the older "waterfall" method, "up to 3x in median case". Prebid's own advice on how many bidders to use and how long to wait rests on its A/B tests with publishers. Michael Smith and six co-authors used the HTTP Archive, a public monthly crawl of millions of websites, to study 145 million header-bidding requests from 616,539 websites over 41 months, but for the user identifiers they carried, not for timing. GitHub searches in November 2026 found single-page inspection tools and auction simulators, but no recurring public dataset of auction timing.
Built with what exists
Playwright (Apache 2.0 licence) driving Chromium; Prebid.js's own event log, read in the page with pbjs.getEvents() (auction start and end, bid responses, timeouts); the Tranco research list of top sites; Python for analysis. The browser carries no login or cookies, names itself as a research bot, and stops each page before the call to the ad server, so no ad is shown and no advertiser pays. Both precautions matter: in March 2025 AdExchanger saw log files of ads served to the HTTP Archive's crawler even though it declares itself as a bot.
First step
Write a Playwright script that loads 100 sites, reads
pbjs.getEvents()where Prebid is present, and saves bidders and timings to a file.Done looks like
Three monthly snapshots in a row, each covering at least 10,000 sites, published with the code, giving per site the bidders, the time limit and the median auction time, plus a repeat run of 100 sites within a day that finds the same bidder list for at least 90 of them.
Open 02 · the brief
Final-auction test suite
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open-source reference version of a publisher ad server's "final auction", the last step that weighs direct deals, the header-bidding winner and exchange bids and picks one ad, plus a public set of test cases with known right answers that any ad server, run in test mode, can be checked against.
Why it is still open
In the US case, the Justice Department and the states that sued with it asked the court to make Google publish DFP's final auction logic as open-source code; a Prebid witness testified that market participants cannot "validate the auction mechanics of DFP's final auction logic" because it is a "black box". The court's remedies opinion, filed on 2 September 2026, rejected the request because its liability findings had not covered that logic. GitHub searches in November 2026 found no test suite for final auctions, Last Look or Unified Pricing Rules; the open-source projects found simulate bidders or run only the header auction.
Built with what exists
Prebid.js and Prebid Server (Apache 2.0 licence) for the header auction; Revive Adserver (GPL 2.0 licence), an open-source ad server, as the first system under test; Python or TypeScript for the reference logic and the test runner; worked examples from the court record, such as the First Look case above. All bids are made up, and no real ads or money are involved.
First step
Write the auction examples in the 2025 liability opinion and the 2026 remedies opinion as 20 test cases with expected winners.
Done looks like
At least 300 published test cases, each giving deals, bids, minimum prices and fees as input and the expected winner and price as output; a reference version that passes all of them; and published pass rates for at least two other open-source setups.